Flyspray - The bug killer!

This is the Bug Tracking System for the Flyspray project. This is not a demo!

2019-04-22: Flyspray 1.0-rc9 released See https://github.com/Flyspray/flyspray/releases

ID Category Task Type Severity Summary Status  desc Progress Assigned To Due In Version Opened Last Edited
2055Backend/CoreBug ReportLowMake the csv export table fields respect the user permi...New
0%
1.1 devel17.09.201517.09.2015 Task Description

Just moved issue #110 from https://github.com/Flyspray/flyspray/issues/110 to here for centralized task tracking.

Maybe just needs testing with current github master.

2057Backend/CoreBug ReportLowDo not resubmit forms on browser reload button or F5New
0%
122.09.201523.09.2015 Task Description

On some forms, when the user presses the reload button of this browser, the POST submit can be resubmitted.

Browsers can warn about this (Chromium, Firefox, Konqueror tested and they show a warning dialog) before executing the second POST.
But people on Flyspray mailing list wrote they experienced double comments.

Simple solution is just HTTP GET redirects after a successful POST. (HTTP 303 or HTTP 302)
But maybe there is a better method than a second roundtrip always needed?

Success, Error, or Warn-messages to the user are stored in the $_SESSION variable for displaying on the second GET request.
But I think that this is a bit ... mmh... not perfect.

For example, I would like to have in the direct response at which position in a form an input error is, not just the message bar in the top center as it is currently that just dissappear after a few seconds.

Also take care the browser back button still works as expected for the user.

2058Backend/CoreBug ReportLowClosing of github.com 'Issues' featureNew
0%
24.09.201524.09.2015 Task Description

As discussed with the team some time ago, a consolidation of places where issues are discussed is wanted.

One of the results was, that we do not want people post issues to github.com Issues and instead use our own bugs.flyspray.org
and to prefer "to eat our own dogfood" and a have central place to handle tasks.

As a result we tried to reduce the open issueas on github.com. I was in the process of moving 2 of still 7 open issues there to bugs.flyspray.org when suddenly the Issues on github.com were closed. :-( Now the last 5 issues there are lost at the moment for me and the audience, which where mostly informations to interested users, not bugs.

I think just closing it without an easy accessible alternative is not the best solution.

At least we should wait until the oauth2 authentication for github users should be implemented and setup on bugs.flyspray.org , so people browsing github.com, finding Flyspray project just can
"Login with github"-feature on bugs.flyspray.org.

The blocker to do this: Currently there is missing an option to "connect" an oauth "Login with github"- Login with an existend flyspray userlogin.

So that one userid in flyspray can:

  • login with username and password
  • login with one or more of his social accounts (github, facebook, microsoft, g+) if they are enabled (would it restrict to github.com accounts for bugs.flyspray.org)
2059Backend/CoreFeature RequestLowusage of github automated/webhook notificationsNew
0%
24.09.201524.09.2015 Task Description

We have no API yet for Flyspray.

But someone could write a simple php-file that can be called by a github.com auto notification, whenever:

  • a commit on github.com for Flyspray/flyspray is made

Github.com provides the configuration of such notification for a possible target like

https://bugs.flyspray.org/api/github.php

or

https://bugs.flyspray.org/api/github.php?project=1

in the settings of a project.

What the file needs:

  • import some of the existing Flyspray classes from includes/
  • config or load the secrets that are provided by github.com in the setup for the automatic notification
  • check that secrets and more for authentication and authorization of requests coming from github.com
  • parse the messages for Flyspray identifiers like ' FS#1234 ' or 'fix  FS#1234 ' or 'related to  FS#1234 '
  • take actions on the results of that message parsing like making adding comment or modifying a task status
2062User InterfaceTODOLowreview do=admin&area=editallusersNew
20%
129.09.201521.01.2019 Task Description

Bugs

  • Small javascript issue: When checkbox of one users row clicked, it doesn’t select the checkbox because the row click event handler doubles the click (check and uncheck, tested with firefox41). Clicking in the row (not on the name) selects the checkbox. fixed
  • browser back button after delete of a user not working as expected. (fix it by redirect 303 , see modify.inc.php how it done for other form submits)

Missing features

  • no sorting possible of the table (like tasklist)
  • no paging (like on tasklist) OK, probably not needed: ~2000 user registrations on bugs.flyspray.org and no problem rendering the table in browser.
  • no filtering of user list possible
  • no helpful information for admins like registration date and last time of login of users (last login time requires a new field in flyspray_users) implemented in Flyspray 1.0-rc7
  • no summary about users like how many exists or how many are currently online (requires storing sessions in a db session (e.g. flyspray_session) table instead php default session directory) on the install. Or a statistic graph of activity or peaks of new registrations over time.
  • maybe show user profile image too in the list.
  • choosable user field columns - partially implemented since 1.0-rc7 by selecting groups of user fields and calculated user fields: user stats, user settings
2063Backend/CoreFeature RequestVery Lowshow closed/open usage count on do=pm&area=XXXNew
0%
29.09.201529.09.2015 Task Description

Currently on

  • do=pm&area=version
  • do=pm&area=os
  • do=pm&area=resolution
  • do=pm&area=status
  • do=pm&area=tags
  • do=pm&area=tasktype

a count of usage in tasks is shown for every property.

Interesting would be if the counter shows the count for open/closed tasks on each row.

2073Backend/CoreBug ReportLowCouldn't edit comment of anonymous reporterNew
0%
17.10.201517.10.2015 Task Description

I wanted edit/fix the comment of an anonymous reporter, but the edit shows empty content on editing..

(here on closed, but non yet implemented  FS#218 )

2074User InterfaceBug ReportMediumOpening tasks from tasklistNew
0%
1.0318.10.201518.07.2016 Task Description

Removing table on row click made it impossible to open a task’ details if you do not display the task id and summary on the task list, because now those two cells are the only clickable items to open a task, instead of the entire line being the hyperlink

2078User InterfaceBug ReportMediumlayout of requested close on small displaysNew
0%
1.026.10.201529.10.2015 Task Description

currently absolute positioning overlapping deny button and not full visible

Possible better solution:

  • cssbased toggle
  • left:50%; width:300px;margin-left:-150px;margin-top:50px;
2089Backend/CoreBug ReportMediumadding same taskid as subtask or related task should be...New
50%
1.0207.11.201518.11.2016 Task Description

Both is a bit illogical, but both is currently possible! ;-)

1 ←- 1

So when setting the parent task id checked for creating loops is needed:

Loop with 2 tasks: 1 ←- 2 ←- 1

Loop with 3 tasks: 1 ←- 2 ←- 3 ←- 1
Loop with n tasks: 1 ←- ... ←- n < – 1

As I think there are currently no recursive reads that could lead to an endless loop, but should be kept in mind when someone wants to programm rendering a gantt chart.
E.g. by limiting the depth of subtasks for example.

2104Backend/CoreBug ReportLowfiltering by one user on tasks with multiple assignees ...New
0%
26.02.201626.02.2016 Task Description

If you have a tasklist with tasks that have multiple assignees in a task and you search just by one of the assignees, the resulting tasklist shows only this user in the assignees column.

Expected: all assignees of the tasks are shown.

2105Backend/CoreFeature RequestMediumcountermeasures for 'add task anonymous' spamNew
0%
127.02.201627.02.2016 Task Description

Today I got first SPAM on bugtracker.

Question: Is it possible to enable CAPTCHA for anonymus task add?

Question 2: Is it possible to delete SPAM tasks.

2114TranslationsTODOMediumStandardize the priority meaning across flyspray transl...New
0%
207.04.201626.03.2018 Task Description

Standardize the priority meaning across flyspray translations.

Idea:

0 - priority unset (database field default value)

1 - defer (or very low priority, often results the task is defered, see “Eisenhower principle”)
2 - low
3 - normal
4 - high
5 - very high

6 - flash (house burns, catastrophic event, website down, “boss” decision)

Some other software (other task planers/ email programs) use a 1-5 step priority. So an export feature to other software may merge priority 6 to priority 5 for such software.

In 2012 meaning was changed only in english translation.

Before normal was priority 2 in a 1-6 range, after it is priority 4 in a 1-6 range.
It should be IMHO 3 in that 1-6 range.

2127User InterfaceFeature RequestLowoverhaul task detail page layoutNew
0%
120.05.201625.05.2016 Task Description

There was a question on the mailing list:

I have a suggestion, even though I don´t know if it´s possible to do it. But if it is, it would be great!
In the comments list of a given task, is it possible that the comments appear from the newest one to the oldest ones, and not as it is now, with the new ones coming at the end of the list? This is because I deal with long comments list for a given task, and it is becoming difficult to reach the last one, that is, the newest comment, because the order in the comments is on the top, the older ones. If this could be altered it would be great. Kind regards
Ana ...

Quick anwsers:

  1. Users can use ‘End’-key and ‘Pos1’-key on their keyboard to scroll to bottom and top of page. (lame anwser I know)
  2. Another quick anwser is to just reverse the comments array in the appropriate template themes/CleanFS/templates/details.tabs.comments.tpl :

Replace

<?php foreach($comments as $comment): ?>

with

<?php
$comments_latestfirst=array_reverse($comments);
foreach($comments_latestfirst as $comment): ?>

But the real problem I think is that the details page (and others too..) is not optimized for todays wide screens (landscape views). Laptops have FullHD or higher but the Flyspray users still have to scroll to get an overview of a task.

And for narrows views too (mobile phones, tablet portrait view)

The attached screenshot shows moving the task details tabs beside their task description if the display width is over 1200 css pixel. (and the reversed comments too ;-) ). Done with pure css media query:

E.g. add to a custom stylesheet file custom_detailswidescreen.css in folder themes/CleanFS/ :

@media only screen and (min-width: 1200px) and (orientation: landscape) {
.details .tab.active{
        display:inline-block;
}
 
.details .tab{
width:44%;
padding-left:0px;
/*margin-top:60px;*/
box-sizing:border-box;
}
 
.details .commenttext pre {
overflow:auto;
}
.details .comment_container .comment {
width:auto;
margin-left:30px;
display:block;
}
.details .comment_avatar {
position:absolute;
}
.details #comments .fa.fa-user{
font-size:30px !important;
}
 
#submenu li a{margin-left:0;}
 
.details #submenu{
display:inline-block;
position:absolute;
padding:1em 0 0;
margin-top:26px;
}
 
.details #content{
display:inline-block;
box-sizing:border-box;
vertical-align:top;
width:55%;
}
 
/* just a temporary fix: should be redone in theme.css with class instead ids*/
#comments, #related, #notify, #remind, #effort, #history {margin-top:72px;}
 
}

(Has still some problems with current 1.0-rc1 when the project selector wraps. Also tab labels wrap if not enough width available and tab content do not adapt.)

What do you think? How should the details page look on different display sizes? How can it improve the workflow of the user?

2137Backend/CoreBug ReportLowfeature accesskey bad implemented by web browsersNew
0%
15.06.201615.06.2016 Task Description

My tests showed that the html accesskey feature is not well and consistent supported by current web browsers and is quite cumbersome to use.
And it seems it will not be better in future..

The only solution I see dropping that feature or replacing them with simple single-key-event javascript listeners, like it is currently done with keys o, j, k, n, and p.

accesskeys in Flyspray I talk about:

  • l (current SHIFT+ALT+l Firefox) login dialog / logout
  • a (current SHIFT+ALT+a Firefox) add new task
  • m (current SHIFT+ALT+m Firefox) my searches
  • t (current SHIFT+ALT+t Firefox) focus taskid search
  • e (current SHIFT+ALT+e + Enter Firefox) edit task
  • x or y? (current SHIFT+ALT+y Firefox) close task
  • s (current SHIFT+ALT+s Firefox) save task

Also related to Keyboard navigation: tabindex

2138User InterfaceFeature RequestVery LowOverhaul dokuwiki editor buttonbarNew
0%
17.06.201617.06.2016 Task Description

Rethink the current sets of buttons and their functionality.

Maybe a mousover hint/cheatsheet of available dokuwiki syntax is more helpful in writing fast and efficient.

  • buttongroup links http,email,ftp
  • buttongroup code, code php: why a single button for php? maybe a cheatsheet or subselect for choosing a language (read directory plugins/dokuwiki/inc/geshi for that). Or even better: Let the project administrator define what source code languages are used/popular in a software project and dependend of that setting prefer/promote that languages
  • I miss a blockquote- or cite-tag for citation, which is more semantic than bold, italic, underline buttons. Update: It is the > character followed by text!
  • Show a cheatsheet (by mouseover?) of dokuwiki smileys as defined at plugins/dokuwiki/conf , update to current config of dokuwiki, facepalm for instance is missing
8-) 8-O 8-o :-( :-) =) :-/ :-\ :-? :-D :-P :-o :-O :-x :-X :-| ;-) ^_^ :?: :!: LOL FIXME DELETEME

8-) icon_cool.gif 8-O icon_eek.gif 8-o icon_eek.gif :-( icon_sad.gif :-) icon_smile.gif =) icon_smile2.gif :-/ icon_doubt.gif :-\ icon_doubt2.gif :-? icon_confused.gif :-D icon_biggrin.gif :-P icon_razz.gif :-o icon_surprised.gif :-O icon_surprised.gif :-x icon_silenced.gif :-X icon_silenced.gif :-| icon_neutral.gif ;-) icon_wink.gif ^_^ icon_fun.gif (not working as first character on a line, bug?) :?: icon_question.gif :!: icon_exclaim.gif LOL icon_lol.gif FIXME fixme.gif DELETEME delete.gif

2139User InterfaceFeature RequestVery LowAdd project setting of popular used programming languag...New
0%
1.1 devel17.06.201617.06.2016 Task Description

This is at the moment just a bit brainstorming ..:

Let the project administrator define what source code languages are used/popular in a software project and dependend of that setting prefer/promote that languages at the dokuwiki editor buttonbar.

This requires probably an additional database field in the flyspay_projects table (if just used for dokuwiki that should be ok)

If thinking further like Filter me all software projects that may ontain CSS code on the projects overview, a m:n-table setup is thinkable. But thats maybe overengineering..
Or can we use the existing tag-feature for that and just ‘tag’ projects with tags?

2159Backend/CoreTODOHighfresh registered user accounts created spam tasksNew
0%
204.07.201625.10.2016 Task Description

Today it was first time I see real spam on bugs.flyspray.org

The 2 spam accounts registered today and started creating spam posts as new tasks.

What is the reason? Was it by real humans or bots?

So what can we do to reduce this in future?

Ideas for making it harder and unattractive for spammers:

  • Users who never opened a nonspam-task or contributed a useful comment should solve a captcha
  • Limit the amount of creating tasks for new registered users or a user groups, like limiting to 2 tasks or 1 task per user per day.
  • Settings for a more moderated task creation process? Like a quarantine dbtable for tasks?
  • If we closed such spam tasks with WTF? reason, it will still be listed by search engines like google at the moment:
  1. Move spam tasks to a ‘dumpster project’, that is not visible for guests (search engines!) too.
  2. Or make spamming to visible flyspray projects unattractive, lets set noindex for: closed task for some special reason id?
  3. Delete spam tasks from database if allowed by your organization

Update: another and this time more aggressive phone number spammer.

2188Backend/CoreBug ReportVery LowIt should not possible to relate a task to itselfNew
0%
01.08.201601.08.2016 Task Description

Flyspray should show a warning, and maybe set the focus back to the field (only when it is a this-one-field-only-form.)

2193User InterfaceFeature RequestLowEdit a comment while seeing task details and other comm...New
0%
07.08.201608.08.2016 Task Description

If someone with ‘edit comment’-permission wants to edit a comment, the edit comment form is shown on an extra page.

This is not optimal, because the editor cannot see task details or the other comments while modifying the comment.

Possible Solutions

  • with javascript is enabled: Stay on the ‘task detail’-page, just the comment changes from a ‘view’ layout to ‘edit’ layout, similiar to the quickedit-feature (like in FS1.0).
  • when javascript is disabled: The ‘edit comment’-page shows task details (check permissions) and other comments too, but maybe a bit narrow, so ‘visible focus’ is on editing the comment.
2215Text RenderingBug ReportLowwrong output of Geshi syntax highlighting for xml codeNew
0%
117.10.201631.12.2017 Task Description

Geshi 1.0.8.17 from https://github.com/easybook/geshi is quite slow at the current integration of Flyspray v1.0-rc3 on the first run. (But any further read uses the cache.)

But it produces garbled output for xml code highlighting:

Example without xml, just format as preformatted code:

<table>blabla</table>

Or as php syntax highlighting (even if it doesn’t contain a real php-tag ;-) ):

<table>blabla</table>

Example with xml choosen as language:

blabla

The table tag is stripped away instead of converting the tag for output inside code/pre tags (by converting the < and > chars). Maybe just a configuration issue?

2308User InterfaceFeature RequestLowimprove user management for adminsNew
20%
127.10.201613.02.2017 Task Description

The register spam by probably bots in 2016 is annoying.

I ticked the setting, that an admin must accept a new registration. It helps to reduce spam task, but now admin must decide if the registrations are ok or just spam bots.

Beside the need of antispam-plugins, the management of users can be improved:

  • column sorting of user list, similiar to the tasklist
  • filtering user list, similiar to the tasklist
  • pagination of user list (25,50,100,200,all?)
  • more columns like ‘last login’, ‘last activity/tasks/comments created/votes/edit’ that may help to decide what status or settings a user should have in future.
  • show time zone setting and language setting of users implemented in userlist now
  • mass accept/deny of a list of user registrations waiting for admin approval.
2325User InterfaceFeature RequestLowbig image attachments: fit to browser window width in L...New
0%
310.01.201711.01.2017 Task Description

Maybe this is not an issue, but my problem is: upload images approximately 3000 px x 2000 px and this image appears larger than the monitor
is it possible that the image is automatically resized to 800 px x xxx px size

(reported by Ivan Cilic)

2332Backend/CoreBug ReportMediumCSV export filename filteringNew
0%
224.01.201724.01.2017 Task Description

The filename for the csv export is build based on project name and current date.

Due different handling of web browsers, the appropriate http header should send the filename in ascii and also provide them as utf-8 for web browsers who can handle that.

Related RFC5987

2337DocumentationInformationLowFlyspray ThemesNew
0%
402.02.201716.02.2017 Task Description
  • Flyspray 1.0 includes 1 default theme CleanFS. That decision was made to reduce maintainance effort and the old blue theme was dropped. Also the CleanFS contains UI-logic implemented in HTML/CSS and tries to be usable even for the people who turned off javascript in their web browsers for security reasons. (and reduces spam on many other websites too without an adblocker)
  • Current Flyspray source and the theme CleanFS provides several methods to customize the layout without touching the .tpl files. These are:
    1. custom_*.css files that extend or overwrite properties of CleanFS/theme.css
    2. 2 fields in admin area where to put code
      ?do=admin&area=prefs#lookandfeel

      For instance a corporate footer menu or something like that.

Advantages of CleanFS instead running your own

  • Theme is maintained with Flyspray source. Detected security issues related with themes are fixed with Flyspray releases.
  • Added features or capabilities are implemented for the default theme.

‘Subtheme’ can be a compromise: Theme CleanFS is always uptodate in sync with Flyspray. Subthemer only needs to check changes required for own subtheme .tpl files.

I do not want complete stop people from writing their whole new template, it allows new ideas implemented or alternative usability. For them, it is probably better to create a Github project for that theme.

This is just raw info from me and can be discussed. Something should be finally written on https://www.flyspray.org in the documentation area.

2436Backend/CoreBug ReportLowdokuwiki renderer creates nonunique html-id for h1,h2,h...New
0%
202.08.201702.08.2017
2439Backend/CoreFeature RequestLowClone a ProjectNew
0%
15.09.201715.09.2017
2440Backend/CoreFeature RequestLowOption to disable tag featureNew
0%
15.09.201715.09.2017
2441Backend/CoreBug ReportMediumrefactor dokuwiki image tagsNew
0%
15.09.201715.09.2017
2444Installer and UpgraderInformationLowcomposer hits memory limitsNew
0%
04.10.201704.10.2017
2453Backend/CoreBug ReportMediumvalidate category before storing a new taskNew
0%
1.014.12.201714.12.2017
2454Backend/CoreBug ReportLowPHP warning in admin edit user areaNew
0%
15.01.201815.01.2018
2491Backend/CoreBug ReportLowgroup member links if project manager but not adminNew
0%
1.001.09.201801.09.2018
2531TranslationsFeature RequestLowdetect usage of translation keywordsNew
0%
110.01.201919.03.2019
2535Backend/CoreFeature RequestLownew optional Flyspray setting: add new users automatica...New
0%
216.01.201921.01.2019
2536Backend/CoreFeature RequestMediumstore session in Flyspray databaseNew
0%
221.01.201915.03.2019
2548User InterfaceFeature RequestLowCSS grid layout for task details page typeNew
0%
05.05.201905.05.2019
2553User InterfaceTODOLowintelligent accesskey shortcut helper dependent of OS, ...New
50%
106.06.201929.07.2019
2554User InterfaceTODOLowkeyboard shortcuts help box should adapt to current pag...New
0%
06.06.201906.06.2019
2559Backend/CoreBug ReportLowa duplicate close accepted even when missing comment/ r...New
0%
peterdd29.07.201929.07.2019
2560Backend/CoreBug ReportLowdo not allow close task with reason duplicate referenci...New
0%
peterdd29.07.201929.07.2019
2572User InterfaceTODOLowadd link attributes ugc and nofollow to user generated ...New
0%
13.09.201913.09.2019
2573Backend/CoreTODOLowadd rel nofollow,ugc,.. settingsNew
20%
peterdd114.09.201915.09.2019
2575Backend/CoreFeature RequestLowability to view and reset Flyspray default settingsNew
0%
19.09.201919.09.2019
2577User InterfaceFeature RequestVery Lowdistinguish between anonymous reporter and deleted userNew
0%
18.10.201918.10.2019
2581User InterfaceFeature RequestLowreplace bitmap icons of default themeNew
0%
31.10.201907.12.2019
2585User InterfaceTODOMediumUpgrade CKEditor to 4.13.0New
0%
peterdd02.12.201903.12.2019
2586Backend/CoreTODOLowPHP7.4New
0%
peterdd1.0-rc1012.12.201912.12.2019
1222Backend/CoreFeature RequestMediumWorkflow engine / Role-based State Transition Rules Eng...Unconfirmed
0%
11625.03.200705.05.2019
1236User InterfaceFeature RequestLowMark Issue As Verified or UnverifiableUnconfirmed
0%
3409.04.200718.07.2016
Showing tasks 151 - 200 of 303 Page 4 of 7

Available keyboard shortcuts

Tasklist

Task Details

Task Editing